Seeking Feedback: American Large 3-row SUVs

Hackrs,

I would trust the collective input from this community leagues before the automotive journalists online when it comes to genuine opinions.

May I have your thoughts on any of the American truck-based SUVs (standard and long wheelbase) & their luxury counterparts:

Tahoe/Yukon/Escalade
Expedition/Navigator
Wagoneer/GW

I’m looking for the quietest interior on the freeway, with the least roll and pitch (I’m not driving it like my E92, just want confident handling).

Fortunately, I have been able to drive all of these in some capacity (some were days long rentals), except the Stellantis products. I’ll be doing that later this month. I’d like to hear from anyone who has lived with any of these cars instead of trying to forecast what my next few years might be like from a 15 minute test drive.

Denali/Escalade would be the nicest but not really worthwhile to lease, Stellantis would be the cheapest. Pick your priority.

If youre looking for something that feels ‘stable’, Id go x7/GLS.

1 Like

I should have specified I was looking at purchasing a CPO.

The RV for a 36/10 Escalade is like… 56%? Actual SoCal market value of a 3 year old Escalade with 50k miles and no warranty is like 76%. It ought to be one of the best leasing luxury vehicles out there lol.

1 Like

Id consider leasing a wagoneer, but i wouldnt be caught dead buying one

3 Likes

No discount, no incentives, high MF. Actual RV doesn’t equal MFTR set RV. In theory, if the RV was set to market, yes, it would be relatively alright to lease.

Ahh I was just being cheeky about the residuals vs real world pricing. I’m familiar with how it works. None of these cars lease well at all.

I do appreciate your insight though. If the X7 had far more cargo space, that would be ideal.

GW is DEAD LAST

Yukon, Navi, Escalade, Expedition, Tahoe

In that order

Hmm I would think the Escalade would be higher than a Yukon.

GMC puts better shocks / tires / etc than a Caddy?

Could I ask if you are listing that as an order of overall satisfaction and perhaps a balance of price, longevity, and quality… or was that specifically in regards to the quietness of the cabin and the perceived/actual agility? Or both.

Forbs, for what it’s worth I last drove a MY23 Escalade for a few days, that had Mag Ride and an e-diff. I don’t know enough if an eLSD is that essential for body control for my regular, pedestrian driving. I recognize it is found on lots of performance vehicles. I am coming from an SUV that feels like a 4D motion simulator at Universal Studios sometimes.

I believe the higher Yukon trims can be optioned with an eLSD, albeit with air suspension. The latest Denali’s seem to come standard with Mag Ride and coils on the front, multi-link rear (edit: like the Escalade).

Yes but those are on a base Escalade, and Escalades have higher trims.

1 Like

Are you planning on towing anything at any time with this ride?

Lease or buy?

Long term or just a few years?

I would be purchasing, ideally a CPO. Plan on having for at least 5 years. I will not be towing anything. It will be a 4WD optioned car.

Yukon XL Denali/Ultimate or AT4.

1 Like

Thank you serotonin

I feel a consensus is forming that confirms your suggestion. There’s a gravitation towards a Yukon with its acoustic laminate glass on the front windows over a Tahoe, plus being equipped with a magnetic ride suspension I really enjoyed in the Escalade.

2 Likes

If it’s just to carry people and stuff, a minivan is better at it.

1 Like

You can’t carry as much stuff and as many people in a minivan as you can a Yukon XL.

Cargo volume for a kia carnival and a yukon xl are almost identical (carnival is slightly more with all seats down)

2 Likes

Carnival is great for all tiny kids. You can actually fit all adults in a Yukon XL and still throw some stuff in the far back.

Tell that to the adults that comfortably sat in the back of my carnival on trips.

Carnival has .5" more headroom, .5" more legroom, and 1" more hiproom in the 3rd row than the yukon xl. It is down about 2.5 inches in shoulder room though.

3 Likes