6 months left on 23 e-tron GT and can’t decide what’s next

6 months left on my 23 Audi e-tron GT lease and trying to figure out the smartest next move.

I’m about 6 months out on a 36/10k lease, sitting at ~12k miles total. Residual is around 69k, so I’m assuming there’s no real equity here even with the low mileage. Kind of a weird spot to be in after only using about a third of the miles, especially coming from ICE cars where that usually mattered.

Part of the confusion is that this e-tron deal was unusually good. Friends and family discount, big Audi incentives at the time, EV credit, plus equity from my M2. All in, it was sub-100k for a 130k car, so resetting expectations now is a bit of a reality check. Doing the math doesn’t help either, roughly 36k over 3 years for about 12k miles, or around 3 dollars a mile. Ouch.

Normally at this point I know exactly what I want next. This time I don’t. For context, prior cars were an M2 Competition, M235, and a 2 Series. That’s more to give flavor than define criteria. I’m not in the two door phase anymore, but this also isn’t the primary family car. We already have a three row SUV, which is why the mileage is so low.

I see plenty of Porsche, BMW, Mercedes around me, and nothing turns my head. The one thing that’s consistently caught my eye is the Rivian R1S. If I had to move tomorrow, that’s probably where I’d land. I’ve also been looking at the BMW M850 Gran Coupe since it has similar proportions to the e-tron GT and feels more aligned with how I drive now. Dealer tried to push me toward an M5, but that’s not really the point for me given traffic, short commute, and how little of the performance I actually use.

I’ve looked at Porsche options like Taycan Cross Turismo, but between pricing, ownership hassle, and a firm veto on wagons at home, I’ve moved on. I’m also not locked into German luxury. Honestly, even the new Kia Telluride looks great and I wouldn’t hate a much lower payment.

What I’m trying to solve for:

  • Around 1k a month, ballpark

  • Fun daily, leaning comfort over horsepower

  • Doesn’t need to haul kids but proper backseat (think executive saloon / GT, not an M3 backseat)

Couple questions for the group:

  • Any cars I should be looking at that lease well and fit this lane?

  • I’ve never used a broker before, but I’ve got three young kids and not a lot of spare time. Happy to pay a fee if it makes sense. Any broker recs in Northern Virginia?

  • Anything creative worth exploring with my current lease if a good deal pops up, or am I best off just riding out the last six months?

1 Like

R1S is a great daily option, I just dislike the charging curve but that’s a personal preference. M5 is cool because it’s a plugin hybrid but the new one is going to depreciate because it is a PHEV. Short commute could rlly benefit from a plugin hybrid which is why you might enjoy the 550e. I’d prefer the M5 over an M850 for a daily commute because of the split personality but for the very same reason, 550e seems even nicer. My guess is only the Rivian leases well. If you’d rlly like the practicality of the Rivian but want a PHEV that has a nice engine roar, maybe consider the X5 50e.

Maybe some more criteria about your preferences would help narrow down to specific car vertical.

I’d happily recommend working with IAC. Smart dude with some very cool tricks up his sleeve to save your money.

1 Like

You can extend your AFS lease another 6 months and buy yourself more time. I did that on my single pay 2023 RS eTron GT. Bonus, if you find a deal before 6 months, you can end the extension early w/o penalty.

1 Like

Just wait 5 months. It’s too early too spend time for this.

6 Likes

I had trouble finding a suitable replacement for my e-tron GT, and finally just picked something I didn’t really want from the LH Value Menu.

Lucid Air and BMW i7 were the closest replacement candidates, but the appeal:dollar ratio wasn’t close enough to what I had with the Audi, so I just went downmarket.

I have some regrets, but in 16 months those will all be behind me.

2 Likes

appreciate that. guess only reason for looking early was either if build allocations were tight and/or there was an option to pull ahead…

thank you for the reply. i think i may head downmarket too. its getting hard to justify my dollars per mile as a commuting car mostly (and my commute is like 10 miles each way). Kia Telluride is high in my mind.

thanks for reply. the M5 is gonna have the same cramped back seats. tho all my kiddos are in car seats, that actually matters. can barely sit in my preferred position with a car seat behind me…

as far as other criteria … to state maybe the obvious, i gotta like the design and looks. i’ve ruled out the Merc AMG GT 4 door for instance because the stance and proportions look ugly to me. In a way, same w Taycan even tho it’s very similar to the e-tron GT.

what else - 4 doors only. no trucks (RAM, GMC), open to suv provided it can be sporty (Cayenne has best looking design but I find the whole process with them to look annoying and expensive…X5M is amazing but too expensive. think the X7 and Merc GLS to be boring and have weird propositions.

i think i keep landing in executive saloon / GT over and over again with sole exception of the Rivian…

You seem to like the car. Why would you use a pull ahead? If you think M5 has cramped seats in the back none of those cars you mentioned will be better.

2 Likes

my mistake - I had assumed the 8 GC would have better legroom in the backseat than the M5 but you are right - they’re both coming in at 36 inches…

Seth Meyers Lol GIF by Late Night with Seth Meyers

Nobody needs to stay in an abusive relationship.

5 Likes

OP have you looked to see if they have any good Taycan deals in your area? We have great deals in SoCal. It’s as close to the same car as you’d probably get.

i did a cursory search and immediately saw 1500 month for 5k miles and said nahhhh…

will look again though - maybe i missed something.

I think you might really like the X5 50e for the practicality and convenience. I encourage test driving it.

1 Like

Jrouleau426 and IAC_Scott always spot crazy Porsche deals. Def worth hitting them up.

2 Likes

thank you!

1 Like

got it. appreciate it.

i feel dumb but i’m just realizing that leasing CPOs is a thing. truly had no idea…

2 Likes

Check this broker out from the forum. Looks like he’d be able to help you ⌚️ AutoTime| JAN. Insane PORSCHE blowout deals. Macan and Cayenne steals! Demo deals! (646) 570-3869 - #619 by AutoTime

1 Like

BMW i4m50. Hatchback design. 4 doors. Room for car seats. Goes fast…

2 Likes