With the assumption of good credit and the hopes your friend lives a lease friendly states the options could be endless. Although bad credit in the worng state will thin out the options quick. But in trying to answer your question 3 or 4 series BMW and the Genesis G70 are in that price point and are cars that move around well.
I’m probably in a small minority of supporters, but we love our GLA250 and our payments are $360/mo with only first payment due at signing. Another member was able to score an AMG/night package trim for even less. If you want to really step it up the GLA45 is a hoot. Really hard to pass up the value here and the amazing service you get w/ MB.
Ford stopped making the Focus/Fiesta so any new RS/ST are late model years and not eligible for lease support. None of these leases especially well, a base WRX or Mazda3 should be well within the budget, the rest you’d have to run the numbers.
None of these cars lease well and usually the sporty trim lack any incentives. My friend flew from NY to NC just to find a dealer with a Golf R willing to go below MSRP.
I leased my GTI Autobahn for an embarrassing $399 / month at the time because I didn’t know better and most dealers wanted $450+ with normal drive offs.
At that price Id rather take a 330i if I had known better.
Certainly subjective, I had both. The GTI was a hoot and the limits were a lot easier to reach safely since it’s FWD. I only drove the F30 328i but with the sport suspension in RWD trim you could have a lot of fun. I actually liked the handling of the 4 cyl more than my 335i, less weight and lower limits again, but no where near as smooth or good sounding.
If I was just shopping from that list I’d consider driving the Veloster N, it’s gotten very very good reviews if you can get over the badge.
GTI is refined compared to the Veloster N. Coworker of mine just bought the Hyundai and can confirm it is a hoot to drive. The only problem is that it has that weird 3rd door, so it’s not very practical.
But price wise, you can’t beat it, I think it’s under 30k for the more powerful version, which would be a travesty if you skipped it.