26% APR on a Used Car loan?

Yikes! Amazing to think this is legal in our country.

Why? No different than most credit cards. Its not like it isnt explained in excruciating detail on the finance contract.

You can only do so much to save people from themselves.

9 Likes

Iieska Packard of Fresno, a 43-year-old licensed vocational nurse, was at her company office last year when a colleague asked, “Isn’t that your car getting towed?” Packard raced down the stairs and out the door, but it was too late. Her 2017 Lincoln MKX was gone.

When Packard bought the vehicle, she put down $2,000 on a purchase price of $21,285, including sales tax and fees. She financed the rest through the dealer with a six-year loan bearing an annual interest rate of 26.2% — even higher than the average 9% to 20% rate that subprime car buyers face, according to the Consumer Financial Protection Bureau.

The sales contract showed Packard’s financing charges over the term of the loan totaling $19,561 — more than the original principal borrowed.

I actually think there is a valid question in @manku’s post. What are interest rates like in other countries, and what kind of “life” does the “average” person have in those countries?

I have no idea how accurate this data is, but it’s a rather interesting table:
https://www.financialadvisory.com/world-credit-card-rates.html

Of the countries listed, the US is the only one which shows a range of ~3.5x btw the lowest and highest interest rate; in fact, it’s one of the few countries that shows a range at all.

I know/have worked w/ people who have varying degrees of financial literacy. Yes, there is only so much you can do to save people from themselves. But there is a valid question of whether the US is particularly bad among industrialized nations about allowing people to hang themselves.

JMHO.

1 Like

Damn writer don’t know Tax Title License is usually over 2k, so she put less down than TTL

Vocational nurse can’t do simple mathematics? I feel worse for her patients then her…

Can she convert lbs to kgs and calculate a dosage appropriately? Yes the computer does all that for you, maybe that’s the problem…

4 Likes

I know I’m being overly pedantic, but, assuming a “vocational nurse” is what I know as an “LVN,” LVNs don’t actually administer meds. I actually don’t think it’s super common outside of ICU settings for nurses to do the calcs for med administration, actually.

Back to the topic… :slight_smile:

As a licensed pharmacist you could probably talk circles around me in that department, but the core issue is that this country has a severe lack of financial literacy. It’s not taught in school, and when it is taught - people don’t pay attention out of the idea ‘when am I going to use this’.

3 Likes

I couldn’t agree more. There is “easy” access to credit. If you’ve received pre-approval letters in the mail from credit card or finance companies, you’ll understand what I mean.

“Packard, a mother of two, says her credit was hurt after she fell behind on student loans and medical bills.”

I do feel bad for her in this case, but did she really need to go out and get a 2017 Lincoln?

1 Like

Financial illiteracy does not mean we should allow predatory lending, be it with credit cards or auto loans.

5 Likes

When you say WE, who are you referring to? The consumer or lawmakers? (I am not trying to bring politics into this discussion). As a consumer who has worked hard to build up my credit over the past 20 years, I have the option of going with a lender that has the best interest rates available.

For folks who have subpar credit for whatever reason, their options are limited. Although, I do not agree with predatory lending, we live in a free market economy. Don’t get me wrong, if companies/lenders are breaking the law, then they should be held accountable.

My friend use to do Lease returns and repo for Honda financial services and we’ve concluded that people are really bad with money and credit. There are cases where people lease a loaded MDX for 1000+ and end up getting repo without making the first payment. People that got repo multiple times. Taking out loans they really can’t afford in the long run etc. etc.

I assure you they are taught med calcs in school and constantly double checking dosages.

Regardless my point is it’s very basic and they make like $35/hr in cali. So something is amuck with her finances in fresno. We need to stop giving ADULTS free passes with these heartstring stories about how they were “suckered”

She fell behind on student loans? Is that before or after they suspended payments on them.

Wait until she sees what the predators in that industry add on to defaulted loans. And that’s not anywhere in the fine print when signing. Def a more pressing issue then overpaying for a luxury brand car you don’t need

3 Likes

What interest rate would you charge to lend your own money to people who historically haven’t paid their bills?

(I’m assuming you don’t run a charity.)

4 Likes

Tucker Carlson, Bernie Sanders, and AOC all threw out the idea of a 15% interest cap back in 2019.

I don’t think this will ever pass in the US, and whenever caps are made, lenders dodge them. John Oliver did a great piece on payday predatory loans and subprime automotive in 2014 and 2016 respectively, which I think everyone should see (even if he is a tad liberal for my taste)

1 Like

Doesn’t matter where you put a cap, you’ll just get more denials, which then results in handwringing over a different form of “unfairness.”

If it was profitable to give 2% (or 5% or 12%) auto loans to people who historically haven’t managed credit well, the market would address it.

1 Like

By we, I mean as US citizens. Granted, I have already lost all hope that any of our lawmakers are able to make a positive change for us at this point.

I have been building credit since I turned 18 and also have a flawless credit history. That does not believe people who haven’t been as fortunate as I have should be ripped off. By allowing these abhorrent exploitative interest rates, the situation for people in a bad spot can only get worse, not better.

There needs to be a cap. I couldn’t care less if it’s a charity or not, predatory lending is predatory lending. There are tons of reasons in this shithole country that someone could fail to pay their bills.

4 Likes

It’s always easier to moralize when it’s other people’s money. :slight_smile:

That’s why I asked the question the way I did.

3 Likes

Maybe at the federal level. Here in MA, there are regulations against predatory lending. Not sure if there is a cap on interest rates or not.

https://malegislature.gov/laws/generallaws/partii/titlei/chapter183c

Credit criminals gotta drive too and cash for clunkers killed the cash car market.

I remember buying running and driving cars for little more than one run flat tire on a 330i costs at the dealer.

1 Like