Review Thread: Benedetto the Broker; Midwest Based & Operate in Most Markets

You text me on the 29th of July looking for a Porsche. I replied with what I though you could do.

You asked for a Porsche Panamera 4s for around $880, to which I said isn’t going to happen.


You’re not someone who has scheduled an appointment with me nor has actually hired me.

You came to me with unrealistic payment expectations, at 430 PM on the 2nd to last day of the month. via text.

This isn’t a review. You’re not a customer.

Edit: Apparently you’re now going to take a BMW too - not a Porsche.

If anyone wants to see what a 4S leases for, in Chicagoland w/ Chicago taxes, here is a base one with 0 DAS and 5k behind invoice.

7 Likes

How can there be any excuse?

Let’s try again

This isn’t a review. You’re not a customer.

5 Likes

Popping in here to say thank you to Ben for walking me through my first out of state deal. While he didn’t secure the deal for me, engaging with him was worth the price 10x over. He was always there to answer all of my dumb questions and offer guidance from his experience. If anyone is reading this and is working through a deal of their own, I would still highly recommend talking to Ben as his advice saved me even more money on my deal!

Thanks Ben!

3 Likes

I will be off today in-place of tomorrow for my scheduled day off this week.

1 Like

Just to let current and potential customers know - I’m having an issue sending texts from my main line.

Not sure what happened, working to get it resolved.

Am still available via call and email.

Edit: Fixed - texts work again!

2 Likes

Edit_ don’t have time for this kind of thing. My original comment was a simple attempt to reach the broker, I have an extremely busy schedule and thought it best to reach out in here because I had a moment to do so. I’ll be using another broker going forward.

I’m not quite sure I understand the issue here.

Edit: Turns out I didn’t. Update below.

To be clear, you didn’t ask me to delete it, you demanded to see proof I had called and then when I mentioned I edited the comment to avoid it coming across negatively (before you mentioned it at all), you said “you need to delete it”. That’s when I said let’s end this relationship and to please refund the fee.

As I mentioned in our messages, I hope you’ll pause and not be so emotional in future client interactions. You were clearly intent on “winning” an argument I didn’t even intend on being in. I was just sending you a quick note to say I’m busy so please just message me the numbers as a call is difficult to coordinate, like I said yesterday.

Just so we’re clear - this is me eating crow.

I certainly should have chosen my words better and I can understand how they come off as demanding.

If you look at my comment, you can see the reply was actually to what you had sent maybe 2 seconds prior re; you need to delete it. The text bubbles show I was replying to myself, before I had even seen your next two messages.

In re-reading your PM(s) it’s clear now that you said you had called from your office line in a later message. My question(s) all revolved around not seeing a call from your cell, that we had been texting back and forth from. Also I had not received a VM from any unrecognized number today, hence my question of what number did you call. I took your first message to mean you had called from your cell.

I’m guessing you took it as me saying I wanted proof, when I asked if you could show me the call. I was typing as you had replied.

As the business it’s on me to make sure I’m understanding the context of the conversation and communicating effectively.

It’s not a stretch to assume some of the issue is us communicating over PM at 3 am and quickly replying without allowing each other to provide context. It’s also near impossible to understand tonality when texting back and forth at the aforementioned, rapid pace.

I’ve PM’d you to address that as well and will be changing my original comments. I’m also happy to discuss on the phone if you’d like.

I apologize and sincerely appreciate the opportunity. I wish you the best with your car search.

1 Like

Reviews only. No requests in this thread

http://www.shopwithben.com/

1 Like

I’d like to give benedetto my praise for the follow up after this mornings incident. We had a breakdown in communication and he took action to see his faults and set things right. I don’t think this should reflect poorly on his rating, instead I would say that it makes him a man of integrity and someone I would likely do business with. I’m sure at 3am I wasn’t at my best and was just as much at fault for the way things went down. If deleting my comments altogether would be the best course of action I’d be happy to do so. Just let me know.

2 Likes

I think we’ll just leave it up.

I’m Italian AND sell cars - drama is just part of the package.

10 Likes

My $.02 as someone with no skin in the game is that exchanges like this between a business and customer (and the resolution) is incredibly important transparency because what you want to see is how people act when things don’t go exactly as they should. Kudos to both of you on resolving this.

7 Likes

A post was merged into an existing topic: Off Topic Landfill


I already left my positive review, but aside from what @28firefighter said (transparency in all things shows all sides of doing business with someone) - Ben had to deal with some dealership drama to get me my Volvo, so he can flip over all the tables he wants.

8 Likes

Just don’t call him “Fredo” :grin:

11 Likes

A post was merged into an existing topic: Off Topic Landfill

I will be out of the office and completely unavailable Sunday.

Call, emails and texts will be returned in the order they were received on Monday.

Just wanted to say that while I didn’t use Ben’s service, he was great in giving me a general idea of whether or not my targeted units would be in my range. In addition, he answered some questions I had on the leasing structure and gave me a recommendation.

In the future, I will use Ben to find a great deal. He sounds like he knows his stuff and I’d highly recommend his service.

1 Like