TIRES, WHEELS AND WHEEL COVERS
• Tires with exposed cords or sidewall damage
• Tires or wheels that do not meet manufacturer’s
guidelines for safe operation
• Missing or damaged wheel covers
• Wheel gouges greater than 1"
If the new tire is same rating as the other three may not be charged but I would assume they will charge you for 1 and be happy if they dont to be safe.
I retuned a Lexus last year Summer and not all four matched; however, each set did match and i would suggest you do that. Inspection was a non issue. Lexus even returned my full MSD sans the disposition fee of course since I went to BMW.
The way I returned it was acceptable to Lexus. My car was RWD so I can’t say regarding AWD also my car was inspected by Autovin and the inspector had no issues. I didn’t get ding for anything and returned my car with almost 45k miles since that’s how many miles was in my contract.
I know for sure you can’t have all mismatched for Lexus, however; if the axles matches at least for RWD then it’s acceptable. I am also inclined to say the same applies to FWD, AWD maybe different.
Ps find a used tire locally that match and swap or look on bestusedtires.com or even eBay.
I have returned cars with non matching tires. I returned a Chrysler lease (through Hann Financial) and I had the front set of tires different than the rear, but the same specs.
I have also returned a Kia with 1 tire of a different brand.