Replace one tire for lease return?

[jeisensc]

M340xi screw in tire

TPMS showed an alert and turns out my front pass tire has a big screw embedded into it and its pretty close to the sidewall (looks like will need a new tire). The lease is ending next year in September, what are my best options to go about it ? I was thinking of getting the same brand with similar tire depth used off ebay (will this cause a problem during lease return) or should buy a brand new tire of same brand just for the damaged side (And then get it shaved from tirerack to match depth of …

You can replace just one tire. Lots of threads about this if you search - including the one I shared, several recommendations on where to get a used replacement tire. You can use any local tire shop