Have you seen what all these other buyers would offer + what blue/black book value is? Don’t just go based off Carvana
Also asking your local dealer to match Carvana, from my experience, isn’t the most effective strategy. They know that Carvana can’t buy your car so have no motivation to match it. Use all these buyers + book value to gauge the value, then offer the car to local dealers at $XXX. Last step can happen after you decide which way you want to go though. Once you have an idea of that $XXXX number, come back here with it. Based on that you can start to evaluate which route would be most cost effective.
Making this decision is just number crunching. First you need the right numbers to crunch.