And what would āproper treatmentā be, in the minds of the doctors to whom youāve spoken?
Maybe your state differs, but I work in the mental health field and worked at a county ER for a yr full time (and was there for training intermittently for several yrs prior). So I have some familiarity with treating the chronically and severely mentally ill.
A problem as big as the homelessness issue (Iām in California) isnāt going to just have one cause, but conservatorship laws (unless theyāve changed substantially in the past 10-15 yrs, which Iām pretty sure they havenāt) donāt prevent effective treatment.
You can conserve all the people you want, but when thereās not enough (or any) beds at state hospitals, there will be no place to send patients who are on conservatorship. And, from a purely practical standpoint, conservatorship can be more about placement in a long-term facility than it is about the day-to-day administration of medication(s).
I would say an equally big problem is that insurance and Medi-Cal (Medicaid in other parts of the country) punish hospitals for keeping patient for more than 3 days but refusing to pay for additional treatment. I was under the strong impression when I worked in the ER that many of the inpatient psychiatric units that accept Medi-Cal (who would accept our patients for transfer) simply kept the patients for 3 days and then would discharge, regardless of the patientās state, because they suspected it would be a fight to get more payment for a longer saty. Theyād happily accept the patients again from us, keep them for another 3 days, and then would stop accepting the patient altogether for the calendar yr when the benefit had run out.
And then the outpatient clinic at county facilities are typically overstaffed (and, until the past few yrs, very low paying). Hard to provide continuity of care when either no one wants to work at the clinic (or when the ones you can hire are not exactly good clinicians). The county has finally decided to join the wage āarms warā btw Kaiser and the prison system and increase salaries (to a startingly high amt, actually).
Sure, the laws might make things more complicated. But some of the old timers who were my supervisors think that the domino effect started when funding was cut for state hospitals.
Not sure how āresolvableā you think these issues are. We do not understand the fundamental mechanism for any defined mental illness (except for those that are consequences of medical illnesses), so resolution isā¦ difficult.
If one of the doctors you spoke to use the term āresolvable,ā I would think that genuinely funny, if it werenāt so tragically wrong.
Back to the topic.