Try Passport in Md, or Cleveland area BMW dealers. If you truly want a deal, you’re going to have to cast your net further than here.
Trying to get a loaner 330 xdrive in NY area. best I can get is 16% off on a MSRP $50K one, others are 15% off…
16% with or w/o incentives? Not all BMW stores are going to give you 20% off a loaner if that’s the intent. The ones mentioned here are a mere fraction of cars sold. It’s going to depend how much they want to play + how badly they want the sale.
Disagree. Last Saturday I got an itch and drove to a dealer about 30 (!) miles away. The CA passed me to the SM. And guess what - the guy used to work with my friend and with my other Volvo GM, and he also remembered me from his old dealership. So I now have a local SM and GM at different dealerships to work with 
And I also met another hackr working part time there LOL
16% off before rebate.
Are they willing to give more discount when negotiate in person?
I would take 16% + rebates in a second. best I can haggle with MA/NH/RI dealers on loaners is 10.4% + rebates.
It depends, really. There are no guarantees in life other than death and taxes. They may see you as a more serious buyer if you come in and work a little more. They may, however, have already given you their rock bottom price. All dealerships work differently.
There’s no harm in trying, outside of potentially wasting some time. Everyone has different opinions on negotiation through email vs phone vs in person. Just be prepared to walk should things not go your way.
16% off before incentives isn’t all that bad, however. 20% has been done, but it’s not easy and not a guarantee either.
Keep in mind, that’s going to be the base model stripper + Acq + TTL. Meh.
For sure! However, it’s a start compared to Bobby Rahal.
WTH? 3 different numbers for a 320xi? It isn’t in the pic: are there VINs tied to those? Doesn’t make sense if not.
And I like how the 330i is “as low as.”
“Oh, sorry, that was on a purple one with hail damage.”