Well if you look closely, the replacement for #1 had a $2000 higher MSRP, and we still come out about $2000 ahead even with higher payment (so no “wash out” there at all). Of course I knew that selling high would mean the new car’s payment would be higher. In fact, I directly address it in a post here:
For #2, I made a conscious decision to get a nicer car, and after applying the positive equity and BonusDrive, the new payment is about $70 more… and I’m not sure how you figure $39k and $54K to be similar MSRPs…