Those are so-so offers (not great). You really don’t want to do a downpayment, read up on MSDs. Between the 2 offers you have, the one with the downpayment is worse than the one without (usually a downpayment should help, not hurt)
You seem to have gotten an OK discount from MSRP (~11%) and based on some of your unconfirmed residual of 57%, the math for the depreciation portion should be