Just wanted to provide an update - the carrier showed up on Saturday with no prior notice. He said he didn’t have my phone number because Vroom’s systems were down. Thankfully we were home (not like we’re going anywhere these days anyway) so I was able to give him the car. Yesterday, Vroom called me with TFS on the line in order to get my authorization to release the payoff amount. The payoff amount had increased by $150 since we are a week past my maturity date. Vroom assured me that they would take care of it since this was out of my control. I received an email today with the Fedex tracking number for the payment to Toyota.
All in all I’m a very happy Vroom customer because although I didn’t make any money on the deal, it still beats returning the car to Toyota and paying a $350 disposition fee!