Confused on trade in tax credit towards lease

Unless I missed it, they need to define “lease price” as there are several ways to define it. Is it the gross cap cost (excluding non-taxable fees) plus taxable lease inception fees not capped? Is it the sum of the pretax monthly base payments plus non-capped, taxable lease inception fees?

You seem to define it as 40000 in your example below…

Just to clarify… the 40000 = Total depreciation + Total Rent charges. This may include taxable fees and assume it can include non-taxable fees… if so, too bad. What you’re describing reflects the sum of the base (pretax) monthly payments which equates to a pretax 36-month base payment of 1111.11. I choose to pay non-taxable fees upfront.

Now, let’s suppose I have non-capitalized taxable fees of 500. This means that your 1111.11 base payment is taxed as well as the 500. If the tax rate is, say, 7%, then your monthly payment including tax = 1188.89. You would also owe 7% x 500 = 35 tax at lease inception. I assume that cash/rebate cap reductions are taxed as well regardless of whether the tax is capped or not. If capped, you’ll pay tax on tax.

Regarding the 20000 trade with a 9800 payoff, your equity = 10200. As such, the sum of the pretax base payments less the trade equity = 29800. The 40000 is not just depreciation in your example. It is total depreciation plus total rental charges. The depreciation captures capitalized fees. Accordingly, the 29800 includes only a portion of the depreciation, the balance is rental charges. The taxable base payment = 827.78. So, the payment w/tax = 885.72. Again, you’ll owe tax on the taxable lease inception fee of 500 at signing.

To summarize…

Total CT Sales Tax = Sales Tax Rate x [(sum of the pretax monthly payments - trade equity) + taxable lease inception fees]

This should hold true whether the traded vehicle was purchased or leased.

I often use the term trading rather loosely. Below is an excerpt from my GMF lease agreement regarding the “trade” of a leased 2019 Buick Envision…

Sounds like GMF treats it like a “trade” if you look at the language.

Agree on almost everything but, at least in CT, it’s not just reduced by trade equity. It’s reduce by total dollar amount of trade. On my truck I leased a month ago my trade was 20k and the pay off was 20600. Since the 20k was higher than the 18k total lease cost I pay 0 sales tax. My monthly lease payment is just depreciation + rent charge.

I used the calculations in my earlier post on the numbers I got on wife’s lease. Her trade is 9800 and payoff is 10,000. Total lease cost is around 17600. Even though we rolled the 200 of negative equity in the payment was reduced by roughly 10 dollars a month by trading in the car.